Back to Blog

Blog

Case Study: What Etsy/Shopify Instant Checkout Success Teaches Us About Walmart + ChatGPT

Sean Dorje

Published

October 16, 2025

3 min read

Case Study: What Etsy/Shopify Instant Checkout Success Teaches Us About Walmart + ChatGPT

Walmart's announcement of ChatGPT integration for instant checkout signals a pivotal shift in retail where AI agents handle product discovery and purchases in a single conversation. With millions using ChatGPT daily to figure out what to buy, and powered by the Agentic Commerce Protocol developed by OpenAI and Stripe, this move transforms shopping from browsing endless product lists to natural conversation. The stakes couldn't be higher: early adopters like Etsy have already seen their stock surge 16% following instant checkout announcements, while Shopify prepares to connect over a million merchants to ChatGPT's massive user base.

Why Walmart ChatGPT Instant Checkout Matters Now

Conversational commerce fundamentally changes how consumers shop. Instead of navigating multiple websites and complex checkout flows, shoppers simply describe their needs in natural language and complete purchases with a single tap. Walmart announced its partnership with OpenAI to enable customers to shop through ChatGPT using Instant Checkout, marking the retailer's commitment to this transformation.

"For many years now, eCommerce shopping experiences have consisted of a bar and a long list of item responses. That is about to change," said Doug McMillon, President and CEO of Walmart Inc. The company recognizes that native AI experiences will be multimedia, personalized, and contextual: a complete departure from traditional search-based shopping.

The technology powering this shift, the Agentic Commerce Protocol, represents an open standard that enables AI agents and businesses to transact seamlessly. Unlike traditional e-commerce platforms that require users to navigate through multiple pages, AI checkout compresses the entire funnel into a conversational interface where product discovery, comparison, and purchase happen within seconds.

Etsy's Early Wins: Proof That Agentic Checkout Converts

The numbers tell a compelling story of user adoption and engagement. More than 700 million people turn to ChatGPT each week for help with everyday tasks, including product discovery. Etsy capitalized on this massive user base by becoming the first merchant partner for Instant Checkout, allowing U.S. users to purchase directly from Etsy sellers through ChatGPT conversations.

Despite facing challenges in traditional metrics with consolidated GMS down 4% year-over-year to $12.6 billion, Etsy's strategic positioning in AI-driven commerce demonstrates forward-thinking adaptation. The company achieved record revenue of $2.8 billion, up 2% year-over-year, while maintaining strong profitability margins.

Etsy's marketplace ended 2024 with nearly 90 million active buyers, providing a substantial user base ready to embrace conversational commerce. The platform's integration with ChatGPT positions it at the forefront of agentic commerce adoption, where AI systems handle purchases while merchants retain full control over orders, payments, and fulfillment.

Shopify's Upcoming Integration: Scaling Conversational Commerce to 1 M+ Merchants

Shopify and OpenAI have teamed up to bring AI-driven shopping experiences directly into ChatGPT conversations, with over a million Shopify merchants preparing to join the platform. This integration allows merchants' products to appear in ChatGPT-powered conversations where users can browse, compare, and buy items without leaving the chat.

The technical infrastructure reveals the scale of Shopify's ambitions. Code strings discovered like "buy_now" and "shopify_checkout_url" embedded in ChatGPT's public assets confirm that Shopify and OpenAI have built a native in-chat purchase flow. This gives Shopify merchants potential access to ChatGPT's 800 million to 1 billion users.

Conversational commerce fundamentally changes the customer journey. Instead of traditional keyword searches and multiple page loads, visitors ask questions, ChatGPT shows product descriptions with reviews and prices, and a "Buy Now" button triggers Shopify's checkout flow, all within one interface. Major brands like Glossier, SKIMS, Spanx, and Vuori are among the merchants preparing to launch.

The integration works through OpenAI's plugin architecture within ChatGPT, accessing real-time Shopify data including product details, inventory, and pricing. Secure checkout flows remain powered by Shopify, ensuring merchants maintain control while benefiting from AI-driven discovery.

Shopify's move aligns with OpenAI's aggressive revenue targets of $125 billion by 2029. By December 2024, Shopify had already begun rolling out Chat API access for real-time customer support on checkout pages, laying the groundwork for deeper AI integration.

The entire purchase journey happening within ChatGPT represents what industry observers call "a game-changer for how products are discovered and bought online."

What Walmart Can Learn and Improve From Etsy & Shopify

The retailer must focus on three critical areas to maximize instant checkout success:

First, product catalog optimization becomes paramount. Walmart's AI-powered systems already leverage AI across the business, reducing fashion production timelines by up to 18 weeks. This same rigor must extend to ensuring all 30 million SKUs are properly structured for AI discovery.

Second, Walmart should leverage its existing AI infrastructure. The company's AI shopping assistant "Sparky" provides a foundation for understanding conversational commerce patterns. Walmart's instant checkout implementation can build on these learnings to create superior recommendation algorithms.

Third, the Agentic Commerce Protocol powering Walmart's ChatGPT integration supports a simplified purchase flow that Walmart can enhance with its logistics capabilities. While competitors struggle with fulfillment, Walmart can offer immediate store pickup options directly within the ChatGPT conversation.

Walmart's stock reportedly gained nearly 5% following the ChatGPT announcement, signaling investor confidence in the retailer's AI-first vision. This momentum provides capital and credibility to invest aggressively in conversational commerce infrastructure.

Guardrails: Fraud, Returns & CX Gaps in Agentic Checkout

Agentic checkout introduces operational complexities that retailers must address proactively. Industry experts highlight three critical risk areas that could undermine the technology's promise.

Fraud detection becomes more complex when AI agents handle transactions. As one payment industry executive noted, "An AI Agent, by the very nature of how it's built, looks very much like fraud. This is a bot. It does not behave like a human being." Traditional fraud detection systems must evolve to distinguish between legitimate AI agents and malicious bots.

The verification challenge extends beyond simple fraud detection. "When agents buying at machine speed with bulk negotiation power, existing payment infrastructure isn't built for it," explained the founder and CEO of Kulipa. Chargebacks become complicated when AI agents make purchases, as verifying intent becomes nearly impossible.

Despite these concerns, payment infrastructure may be more ready than critics suggest. "The reality is that payment infrastructure is already equipped for agentic commerce. Tokenization exists, authentication frameworks are in place, and PSD3 addresses delegated authentication concerns," countered another industry expert.

Current limitations reveal the technology's early stage. Instant Checkout only supports single SKUs: multi-item carts remain unavailable. This constraint forces retailers to rethink bundling strategies and cross-selling opportunities that traditional e-commerce excels at delivering.

Retailer Readiness Checklist for the Agentic Commerce Era

Retailers preparing for agentic commerce must fundamentally rethink their digital infrastructure. "If machines can't read it, customers won't see it," warns Heather Hershey, research director at IDC. This stark reality demands immediate action across multiple fronts.

Structured data becomes the foundation of AI visibility. In an AI-first discovery landscape, visibility is earned through structured knowledge, authoritative content, embedded trust signals, and machine-readiness of product and brand data. Retailers must audit their entire catalog for schema markup completeness, ensuring products include FAQPage schema, pricing data, availability status, and customer reviews in structured formats.

The shift to agentic AI systems that autonomously execute workflows requires retailers to adapt their commerce platforms. These systems don't just assist: they autonomously optimize supply chains, reshape customer engagement, and control discovery, pricing, and transactions.

IDC research emphasizes the urgency: "IT buyers should anticipate an AI takeover of consumer shopping, B2B procurement, and business operations within a shockingly short time horizon." Retailers must prepare for AI agents to become the primary interface between businesses and customers.

Practical implementation steps include:

Implementing comprehensive schema markup across all product pages
Creating AI-readable product feeds updated in real-time
Building APIs that support conversational queries, not just transactional requests
Developing return and customer service protocols for AI-initiated purchases
Training customer service teams to handle AI agent interactions

Key Takeaways & Why GEO Matters

The convergence of Walmart, Etsy, and Shopify around instant checkout reveals agentic commerce as retail's new battleground. Early movers gain access to ChatGPT's massive user base while shaping consumer expectations for frictionless, conversational shopping.

Three critical insights emerge from this case study:

First, market validation is undeniable. Etsy's 16% stock surge and Walmart's 5% gain following their ChatGPT announcements demonstrate that investors recognize agentic commerce as a growth driver, not an experiment.

Second, scale happens fast in conversational commerce. With over 700 million people using ChatGPT weekly and Walmart operating 10,750+ stores globally, the infrastructure exists for rapid adoption once technical integration completes.

Third, machine-readability determines success. As IDC's research confirms, "If machines can't read it, customers won't see it." Retailers must optimize their entire digital presence for AI discovery through structured data, authoritative content, and comprehensive schema markup.

For businesses preparing for this shift, Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) becomes essential. Unlike traditional SEO that targets search engine algorithms, GEO ensures products and content appear prominently in AI-generated responses. Companies like Relixir specialize in this emerging discipline, helping businesses achieve visibility across AI search engines and conversational commerce platforms.

The lesson from Etsy and Shopify's early success is clear: retailers who optimize for AI discovery today will dominate conversational commerce tomorrow. Walmart's entry validates the market opportunity, but success requires more than integration: it demands a fundamental reimagining of how products are structured, described, and delivered in an AI-first world.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Walmart's ChatGPT instant checkout matter now?

What early results has Etsy seen from instant checkout?

Etsy's implementation of instant checkout provides concrete evidence that agentic commerce drives real business results. The marketplace saw its stock surge 16% on the day OpenAI announced the feature, reflecting investor confidence in the revenue potential of conversational commerce. Etsy capitalized on this massive user base by becoming the first merchant partner for Instant Checkout, allowing U.S. users to purchase directly from Etsy sellers through ChatGPT conversations.

How will Shopify integrate instant checkout within ChatGPT?

Shopify and OpenAI have teamed up to bring AI-driven shopping experiences directly into ChatGPT conversations, with over a million Shopify merchants preparing to join the platform. Code strings discovered like "buy_now" and "shopify_checkout_url" embedded in ChatGPT's public assets confirm that Shopify and OpenAI have built a native in-chat purchase flow. The integration works through OpenAI's plugin architecture within ChatGPT, accessing real-time Shopify data including product details, inventory, and pricing.

What advantages can Walmart leverage versus Etsy and Shopify?

Walmart brings unique advantages to instant checkout that neither Etsy nor Shopify can match. Operating more than 10,750 stores globally, Walmart can leverage its physical footprint for same-day pickup and returns, solving a key friction point in AI-driven commerce. The company's AI shopping assistant "Sparky" provides a foundation for understanding conversational commerce patterns. Walmart's instant checkout implementation can build on these learnings to create superior recommendation algorithms.

What are the main risks and current limitations of agentic checkout?

Fraud detection becomes more complex when AI agents handle transactions. Chargebacks become complicated when AI agents make purchases, as verifying intent becomes nearly impossible. Instant Checkout only supports single SKUs: multi-item carts remain unavailable.

Why does Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) matter, and how does Relixir help?

Sources

Table of Contents

Title

<- Previous

Next ->

The future of Generative Engine Optimization starts here.

Get a demo

The future of Generative Engine Optimization starts here.

Get a demo

Company

Resources

Security

Cookie Settings

Docs