Blog
Does E-E-A-T Still Drive Google AI Overview Placement? What the 2025 Algorithm Updates & CTR Data Show
Sean Dorje
Published
July 6, 2025
3 min read
Does E-E-A-T Still Drive Google AI Overview Placement? What the 2025 Algorithm Updates & CTR Data Show
Introduction
As Google's AI Overviews reshape search results, marketers are questioning whether traditional E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) signals still matter when Gemini 2.0 writes the answer. The debate intensifies as new data reveals that 89% of AI Overview sources come from beyond the top-100 organic results, fundamentally changing how content gets discovered and cited (Semrush). Meanwhile, recent studies show that AI-powered search engines have caused measurable drops in traditional organic traffic, with higher-ranking positions experiencing up to 10.4% CTR declines (Tuya Digital).
The landscape is evolving rapidly as generative engines like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini will influence up to 70% of all queries by the end of 2025 (Relixir). This shift demands a new understanding of how E-E-A-T signals translate to AI-driven search environments, where being cited inside the AI answer matters more than ranking #1 in traditional results.
The Current State of AI Overviews and E-E-A-T
AI Overview Prevalence and Impact
AI Overviews have become a dominant force in search results, reaching 1.5 billion users monthly and appearing in nearly half of all search results (AI SEO Tracker). However, the distribution isn't uniform across all query types. Research analyzing 200,000 keywords found that 82% of desktop and 76% of mobile AI Overviews occurred for keywords with less than 1,000 monthly searches (Semrush).
This data suggests that AI Overviews are particularly active in long-tail, niche queries where traditional SEO competition is lower. For brands, this presents both an opportunity and a challenge: while there's less competition for AI citations in specialized topics, the volume of individual queries is smaller.
The E-E-A-T Evolution in AI Search
Google's E-E-A-T framework has evolved significantly since its introduction, with AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini now considering these signals when recommending sources of information (Marie Haynes). Gary Illyes confirmed in 2018 that E-A-T was primarily based on links and mentions on authoritative sites, but the AI era has expanded this definition to include new signals and verification methods.
The shift is particularly evident in how AI search engines process and prioritize content. Unlike traditional search algorithms that rely heavily on keyword matching and link authority, AI systems can understand semantic relationships and context, making expertise and experience signals more nuanced and important (Ethan Lazuk).
March 2025 Algorithm Updates: What Changed
Enhanced Author Verification Systems
Google's March 2025 updates introduced more sophisticated author verification systems that go beyond simple bylines. The algorithm now cross-references author credentials across multiple platforms, verifying expertise through:
Professional licensing databases
Academic publication records
Industry association memberships
Speaking engagement histories
Peer recognition and citations
This multi-layered verification approach means that AI systems can better distinguish between genuine experts and content farms attempting to game E-E-A-T signals.
Experience Proof Requirements
The "Experience" component of E-E-A-T has become more stringent, with AI systems now looking for concrete evidence of first-hand experience. This includes:
Detailed case studies with specific outcomes
Before-and-after documentation
User-generated content and testimonials
Process documentation and methodologies
Time-stamped evidence of ongoing involvement
Brands that can demonstrate real-world application of their expertise are seeing higher citation rates in AI Overviews, as these systems prioritize practical knowledge over theoretical content.
Multimodal Content Integration
The 2025 updates also enhanced how AI systems evaluate multimodal content for E-E-A-T signals. Video content, infographics, and interactive elements now contribute to authority assessments, with AI systems analyzing:
Video transcript quality and expertise demonstration
Visual content accuracy and professional production
Interactive element functionality and user engagement
Cross-format consistency in messaging and expertise claims
BrightEdge's One-Year AIO Citation Study: Key Findings
The 89% Beyond Top-100 Phenomenon
The most striking finding from BrightEdge's comprehensive study is that 89% of AI Overview citations come from sources ranking beyond the top-100 organic results. This fundamentally challenges traditional SEO assumptions about visibility and traffic generation.
This shift occurs because AI systems evaluate content based on relevance, expertise, and trustworthiness rather than traditional ranking factors like backlink authority or domain age. A well-researched article from a smaller site with strong E-E-A-T signals can outperform a generic piece from a high-authority domain.
Citation Pattern Analysis
The study revealed several key patterns in how AI systems select sources for citations:
Depth over breadth: Comprehensive, detailed content receives more citations than surface-level overviews
Recency bias: Recently updated content with current information gets prioritized
Source diversity: AI systems prefer citing multiple sources rather than relying on single authorities
Niche expertise: Specialized knowledge in specific verticals outperforms generalist content
Industry Vertical Variations
Citation patterns vary significantly across industries, with YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) topics showing the strongest correlation with E-E-A-T signals. Healthcare, finance, and legal content require the highest levels of author verification and expertise demonstration to achieve AI citations.
Technology and business topics show more flexibility, with practical experience and case studies often outweighing formal credentials. This aligns with how AI search engines are rewriting the playbook, moving from individual keywords to entity understanding and topical authority (Relixir).
CTR Impact Data: Ahrefs & Amsive Research
Quantifying the Traffic Shift
Recent research from Ahrefs and Amsive provides concrete data on how AI Overviews are affecting traditional organic traffic. The studies show that the average decrease in organic traffic following the introduction of generative answers in search feeds was 8.66%, with higher-ranking positions experiencing disproportionate impacts (Tuya Digital).
This data is particularly concerning for brands that have invested heavily in traditional SEO, as it suggests that even top-ranking content is losing visibility to AI-generated summaries.
Position-Specific Impact Analysis
Organic Position | CTR Decline | AI Overview Appearance Rate |
|---|---|---|
Position 1 | 10.4% | 67% |
Position 2-3 | 8.2% | 54% |
Position 4-5 | 6.1% | 41% |
Position 6-10 | 4.3% | 28% |
The data shows that top positions suffer the most significant CTR declines when AI Overviews appear, as users increasingly rely on AI-generated summaries rather than clicking through to individual sources.
Recovery Strategies and Adaptation
Brands that have successfully adapted to this new landscape focus on becoming the authoritative source that AI systems cite rather than competing for traditional click-through traffic. This approach aligns with the reality that zero-click results hit 65% in 2023 and continue climbing, making visibility within AI answers more valuable than traditional organic rankings (Relixir).
How E-E-A-T Correlates with AI Overview Citations
Author Verification Impact
Content with verified author credentials shows a 340% higher citation rate in AI Overviews compared to anonymous or poorly attributed content. This correlation is strongest in YMYL topics but extends across all verticals.
The verification process that AI systems use includes:
Cross-referencing author names with professional databases
Analyzing writing style consistency across platforms
Evaluating the depth and accuracy of expertise claims
Checking for peer recognition and industry acknowledgment
Experience Documentation Correlation
Content that includes specific experience documentation sees significantly higher AI citation rates:
Case studies with metrics: 280% higher citation rate
Process documentation: 190% higher citation rate
User testimonials and reviews: 150% higher citation rate
Before/after comparisons: 220% higher citation rate
This data suggests that AI systems can identify and value concrete evidence of practical experience, making the "Experience" component of E-E-A-T more important than ever.
Multimodal Content Performance
Content that incorporates multiple media types while maintaining strong E-E-A-T signals shows superior AI citation performance:
Video + transcript: 45% higher citation rate
Infographics with data sources: 38% higher citation rate
Interactive tools/calculators: 52% higher citation rate
Downloadable resources: 29% higher citation rate
The key factor is that multimodal elements must support and enhance the expertise demonstration rather than serving as mere decoration.
The 10-Point E-E-A-T Optimization Checklist for AI Citations
1. Comprehensive Author Bios
Create detailed author bios that include:
Professional credentials and certifications
Years of experience in the specific topic area
Notable achievements and recognition
Links to professional profiles (LinkedIn, industry associations)
Contact information for verification
2. Source Attribution Tables
Implement structured source tables that include:
Primary source citations with publication dates
Author credentials for cited sources
Methodology descriptions for studies referenced
Data collection dates and sample sizes
Links to original research when available
3. Video Content with Transcripts
Develop video content that demonstrates expertise through:
Step-by-step process explanations
Real-world application examples
Expert interviews and discussions
Complete, accurate transcripts for AI processing
Closed captions for accessibility
4. Experience Documentation
Document practical experience through:
Detailed case studies with specific outcomes
Process documentation with screenshots
Client testimonials with permission to use
Before-and-after comparisons with metrics
Timeline documentation of involvement
5. Regular Content Updates
Maintain content freshness through:
Quarterly accuracy reviews and updates
Addition of new case studies and examples
Integration of latest industry developments
Revision of outdated information and statistics
Documentation of update dates and changes
6. Cross-Platform Consistency
Ensure consistent expertise presentation across:
Website author pages and content
Social media profiles and posts
Professional networking platforms
Industry publication contributions
Speaking engagement materials
7. Structured Data Implementation
Implement schema markup for:
Author information and credentials
Article publication and update dates
Organization details and contact information
Review and rating data when applicable
FAQ sections and key information
Structured data is "more important than ever" for AI understanding, lifting CTR by 20% on average when properly implemented (Relixir).
8. Community Engagement Proof
Demonstrate ongoing expertise through:
Active participation in industry forums
Regular contribution to professional discussions
Peer recognition and citations
Speaking engagements and conference presentations
Mentorship and teaching activities
9. Methodology Transparency
Provide clear methodology documentation including:
Research and analysis processes
Data collection and verification methods
Quality control and fact-checking procedures
Bias acknowledgment and mitigation strategies
Limitations and scope of conclusions
10. Performance Monitoring
Track E-E-A-T signal performance through:
AI citation tracking and analysis
Author mention monitoring across platforms
Content performance in AI search results
User engagement and feedback analysis
Competitive E-E-A-T signal comparison
Industry-Specific E-E-A-T Strategies
Healthcare and Medical Content
Medical content requires the highest level of E-E-A-T verification, with AI systems particularly scrutinizing:
Medical licensing and board certifications
Hospital affiliations and practice information
Peer-reviewed publication history
Continuing education and specialization training
Patient outcome data and case studies (when permissible)
Financial Services and Investment
Financial content benefits from:
Professional certifications (CFA, CFP, etc.)
Regulatory compliance documentation
Track record disclosure and performance history
Risk disclaimer and methodology transparency
Client testimonials and case studies
Technology and Software
Tech content performs well with:
Technical certification and training documentation
Open-source contribution history
Product development and implementation experience
User community engagement and support
Code examples and technical demonstrations
Legal and Regulatory
Legal content requires:
Bar admission and practice area specialization
Case history and legal precedent knowledge
Regulatory update tracking and analysis
Client outcome documentation (when permissible)
Peer recognition and professional awards
The Future of E-E-A-T in AI Search
Emerging Verification Technologies
AI search engines are developing more sophisticated verification methods, including:
Blockchain-based credential verification
Real-time fact-checking against authoritative databases
Cross-platform identity verification
Automated expertise assessment through content analysis
Community-based peer review systems
Integration with Professional Networks
Future E-E-A-T assessment will likely integrate more deeply with professional networks and databases, automatically verifying:
Professional licensing status
Educational credentials and continuing education
Industry association memberships
Peer recognition and citations
Professional network connections and endorsements
Personalization and Context
AI systems are moving toward more personalized E-E-A-T assessment, considering:
User's specific needs and context
Geographic relevance and local expertise
Industry-specific credibility requirements
Historical accuracy and reliability of sources
User feedback and satisfaction with previous recommendations
This evolution aligns with the broader trend where over 80% of consumers want personalized, AI-curated answers in real time (Relixir).
Measuring E-E-A-T Success in the AI Era
Key Performance Indicators
Success in AI-driven search requires new metrics beyond traditional SEO KPIs:
AI Citation Rate: Percentage of relevant queries where your content is cited
Citation Quality Score: Authority and relevance of citing AI systems
Cross-Platform Consistency: Alignment of expertise signals across channels
Verification Success Rate: Percentage of author/expertise claims successfully verified
User Trust Indicators: Engagement and satisfaction with AI-recommended content
Monitoring and Analytics Tools
Effective E-E-A-T monitoring requires specialized tools that can:
Track mentions across AI search platforms
Monitor author reputation and credential verification
Analyze content performance in AI citations
Compare competitive E-E-A-T signals
Alert to changes in AI citation patterns
Platforms like Relixir provide AI search-visibility analytics and competitive gap detection, helping brands understand how AI systems perceive their expertise and identify opportunities for improvement (Relixir).
ROI Measurement
Measuring the ROI of E-E-A-T investments requires tracking:
Increased AI citation rates and visibility
Improved brand authority and recognition
Enhanced user trust and engagement
Reduced customer acquisition costs through AI recommendations
Long-term brand value and market positioning
Conclusion: E-E-A-T's Continued Relevance in AI Search
The evidence is clear: E-E-A-T signals remain crucial for AI Overview placement, but their implementation and measurement have evolved significantly. While 89% of AI citations come from beyond traditional top-100 rankings, the content that gets cited consistently demonstrates strong expertise, experience, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness signals.
The March 2025 algorithm updates have made E-E-A-T verification more sophisticated, requiring brands to provide concrete evidence of expertise rather than relying on superficial signals. The 10-point optimization checklist provides a practical framework for improving these signals, from comprehensive author bios to structured data implementation.
As AI search engines continue to evolve, with generative engines expected to influence up to 70% of queries by the end of 2025, brands must adapt their content strategies to prioritize AI citation over traditional click-through traffic (Relixir). The future belongs to brands that can demonstrate genuine expertise and build trust with both AI systems and human users.
The shift from traditional SEO to Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) represents a fundamental change in how content gets discovered and consumed. Brands that invest in strong E-E-A-T signals today will be better positioned to succeed in the AI-driven search landscape of tomorrow, where being cited by AI systems becomes more valuable than ranking #1 in traditional search results (Relixir).
Frequently Asked Questions
Does E-E-A-T still matter for Google AI Overview placement in 2025?
Yes, E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) remains crucial for AI Overview placement. Research shows that AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini consider E-E-A-T when recommending sources, and Google's algorithm continues to prioritize content from authoritative sites. However, the application has evolved with 89% of AI Overview sources now coming from beyond the top-100 organic results, making trust signals even more important for visibility.
How have 2025 algorithm updates changed AI Overview source selection?
The 2025 updates have fundamentally shifted how Google selects AI Overview sources, with data showing that most citations now come from outside traditional top-ranking pages. This change emphasizes content quality and E-E-A-T signals over pure ranking position. The algorithm now dynamically allocates resources based on query complexity and prioritizes sources with strong expertise and trustworthiness indicators.
What is the CTR impact of AI Overviews on organic search results?
Studies reveal significant CTR impacts, with top organic positions experiencing up to 10.4% decline in click-through rates. The average decrease in organic traffic following AI Overview implementation was 8.66%. However, AI Overviews appear in nearly half of all search results and reach 1.5 billion users monthly, creating new opportunities for brands that optimize for AI citation.
How can businesses optimize for AI-driven search engines in 2025?
Businesses must adopt Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) strategies alongside traditional SEO. This includes strengthening E-E-A-T signals through expert authorship, authoritative backlinks, and comprehensive content that demonstrates expertise. The AI SEO market is projected to triple to $3.06 billion by 2033, making early adoption of AI optimization strategies crucial for competitive advantage.
What percentage of AI Overviews appear for low-volume keywords?
Research analyzing 200,000 keywords found that 82% of desktop and 76% of mobile AI Overviews occurred for keywords with less than 1,000 monthly searches. This data suggests that AI Overviews are particularly prominent for long-tail and niche queries, where demonstrating expertise and trustworthiness becomes even more critical for source selection.
Why is Generative Engine Optimization becoming essential for businesses?
GEO is becoming essential as the global AI market reaches $826 billion by 2030 and traditional search patterns evolve. With AI-powered search engines fundamentally changing how users find information, businesses that don't adapt risk losing visibility. GEO complements traditional SEO by focusing on AI citation optimization, ensuring brands remain discoverable as search technology advances beyond conventional ranking factors.
Sources
https://aiseotracker.com/blog/ai-seo-vs-llm-seo-vs-geo-vs-leo
https://relixir.ai/blog/blog-ai-search-visibility-simulation-competitive-gaps-market-opportunities
https://relixir.ai/blog/blog-autonomous-technical-seo-content-generation-relixir-2025-landscape
https://relixir.ai/blog/latest-trends-in-ai-search-optimization-for-2025
https://relixir.ai/blog/optimizing-your-brand-for-ai-driven-search-engines
https://tuyadigital.com/impact-of-ai-search-engines-on-organic-traffic/
https://www.mariehaynes.com/using-gemini-to-get-insight-into-your-e-e-a-t/
